Let’s Talk LUFS
June 6, 2024
If you believe that your mix at -7 LUFS will sound significantly better than at -14 LUFS, despite the level matching that streaming sites implement, this video is for you.
I mastered my mix of Krave Amiko’s “Oh So Badly” at -14, -10, and -7 LUFS, and then I level matched them (just as the streaming sites do) and I cut them all together for you to hear for yourself just how much of an advantage (or disadvantage) loudness offers you.
Enjoy,
Mixerman
Transcript
Let’s talk LUFS.
All right, so I have three versions of the same mix at different levels. The first is at -14, the second is at -10, and the third is at -7. Let me just clear these gain adjustments here for you, so you can see clearly that the -14 LUFS mix is much more dynamic than the -7 LUFS mix.
Okay, now let’s just take a listen so we can demonstrate this. You can tell graphically, but let’s just listen.
[Music]
Okay, that got louder each time I went to the next mix. Now let’s bring in RX. I have here the -7 LUFS mix, and I’ll show you that it reads -7 LUFS integrated, which means for the whole mix. And I have my -10 LUFS mix here, and you can see it’s -10 integrated, which is how we measure LUFS. And we have -14.1, close enough, for the quietest mix.
All right, so what I did was I level matched all these mixes at the file level, which is what these adjustments are. I brought the -10 LUFS mix down 4 dB, and the -7 LUFS mix down 7 dB. And if I switch between them…
[Music]
Again, you can hear that they’re level matched, and they sound very close to the same level.
So what I did was I took my cutting tool and grabbed sections from the -10, the -14 and the -7 LUFS mixes. You can tell by the color. I basically grabbed them from these mixes, dragged them up, and made a mix that goes back and forth between all the different versions. Let’s take a listen to that, and then we shall discuss.
[Music]
All right, so what did we learn? Well, once you level match, there’s not an enormous difference between these mixes. There are differences, and those differences would actually become a little more apparent if you were listening down. For instance, the -7 LUFS: I hear the distortion anytime it switches. I hear that excess of distortion.
You know, if I was really going to try and make this mix -7 LUFS… And by the way, this is Krave Amiko, and the song is “Oh So Badly.” I mixed this for them, and I did it on stream, so if you want to see me stream this mix, you can. And, you know, I master mixes right in my mix session. The original mix was at -10, and so I brought the limiter down for -14, and I goosed it up for -7.
If I was really trying to go for a -7 LUFS mix on this, for whatever reason, then I would probably have to take some low end off, so I didn’t get quite so much distortion. I did experiment with a clipper on it. I don’t have transients that are sticking out that much. It really didn’t buy me anything. I’d probably have to mess with it a bit to get it so it sounded the way I wanted.
I can hear balance differences between them, but they’re really kind of minor. But the -10 LUFS is probably the best representation of how I’ve heard this record.
As you can hear when we switch between these, the -14 to the -10 to the -7, it doesn’t change so much where you would go, “Oh my God, the -7’s so much better.” In fact, this experiment reveals that the -7 doesn’t actually sound nearly as good as the -10 or the -14, because of that excess of distortion.
I don’t mind distortion. I like distortion. But that is not distortion that I planned on having on this track. So when that distortion gets added, that’s a problem, right? And now I’m doing it on my mix. Imagine you send it to a mastering engineer. He can’t really adjust your levels. He can adjust your EQ, which, on low end, will adjust your levels. But if you have excessive transients, that’s why a mastering engineer will use a clipper. He wants to knock down your transients a bit so that he can get the whole thing louder, so the limiter is not reacting so much to the transients. So he’s doing a balance move on your mix, basically.
So the reason we measure LUFS as integrated is we want to know, basically, the dynamic range of the entire track. And, you know, at -14 LUFS, we’ve got a big jump in level from the verse to the chorus. Let’s just take a listen to that really quick.
[Music]
Okay, so there was obviously less dynamic between the verse and the chorus. Did it kill it at -7? No, it still had a dynamic change. But there has been no value added by making it louder. I don’t even know that there’s value added. There’s definitely not value added going from -14 to -10.
The value in the loudness really is in how it represents itself in noisy environments, or when you’re listening at low volume. So if you’re in the office, and they have music in the background, in the corner, playing off a Bluetooth speaker, the louder mix is going to translate better, because it’s louder. It’s denser. But does it really make the mix better? No.
So do you really want to make it so that people can enjoy your mix at minimal volume? I mean, that’s up to you.
So anyway, I wanted to do this experiment. I wanted you all to hear this. Let me know what you think. Comments, anything. But I think it’s pretty clear that you’re not gaining all that much with loudness.
Okay, so when the streaming site takes your -7 LUFS mix and brings it down 7 dB, my friends, it’s a -14 LUFS mix. Except now you don’t have the dynamic range to go with it.
All right, but this idea that, oh, when you make it louder, it’s denser and it’ll sound better… And then when we do it, and we switch back and forth between them, we’re like, well, wait a second. You could barely even… You know, if I wasn’t really paying attention, I wouldn’t necessarily notice those switches, right?
Let me know what you think.
